Bluff the reader challenge!

With apologies to Peter Sagal and Wait, Wait…Don’t Tell Me!, today’s wine news roundup is presented in the form of a bluff the reader challenge. Today you are playing for Steve in St. Helena, CA. Spot the one fake story below, and I’ll write the footer for Steve on all his outgoing email messages!

A) It’s not news that the Chinese love of wine has been growing. But what is news is that the Changyu Pioneer Wine Co. will be building a “wine city” on 1,000 acres in Shandong province. With an expected budget of nearly $1 billion, the attraction will blend wine research, wine making and tourism including a European-style village, vineyards, an international wine trading center, and two wine and brandy chateaus that will be among the world’s largest wine and brandy production facilities. Put it on your calendar to stop by and say “ganbei” starting in 2016.

B) In the Northern Rhone, growers on Hermitage hill have long produced wines coveted around the world. Although the hill famously has panels demarcating the various vineyards, the growers there are protesting what they perceive as a blight on the visual landscape: a sixty-foot high cell phone tower that would be visible behind the hill’s famous chapel. Although operator TDF already has a tower on the hill, this new tower from Itasim has irate growers promising legal action if they cannot prevail via other means. “There’s already one tower that disfigures the landscape that is part of our national heritage,” one local official exclaimed. “Don’t make it two!”

C) Wine enthusiasts at the Olympics in London this month will have a lot to cheer about. Trying to underscore the huge strides dining in Britain has taken over the past couple of decades, authorities will be opening the taps–to wine though, not beer. Wine-in-a-keg stations will be at every venue and each pour will be explicitly priced 50p less than any beer offerings. In a backhanded blow to France, the fresh pours available will consist of Mosel Riesling, sauvignon blanc from New Zealand, Semillon from the Hunter Valley, pinotage from South Africa, and Pinot Noir from British Columbia. To highlight the domestic industry, an English sparkling wine will also be on tap using a pressurized keg system developed by Ridgeview.

D) Fans of “natural wines” in Rome have more to dispair than a stuck fermentation. Authorities there have have fined a wine shop owner for a sign designating a selection of wines in his shop as “natural;” criminal charges might even be in store for the shop’s owner. The crime is consumer fraud since “natural wine” has no official meaning. The blogopshere erupted in cries of a “crackdown” and pointed out that the shop, one of Rome’s oldest dating back to 1929, is being made a high-profile example in what could be a newly aggressive stance at the Ministry of Agriculture.

pixel

17 Responses to “Bluff the reader challenge!”


  1. It’s C – the Olympic story. Quite apt, given the amount of fake athletes the olympic games have produced LOL!


  2. Is it D?


  3. C? A BC Pinot Noir? Nobody hates France that much…


  4. It’s A, China’s “Wine City.” I read about it on HuffPo.


  5. Hopefully no one Googled this for their answer. I think the Brits are not going to give up on beer that easily. I’ve had a decent BC Pinot. Though I couldn’t imagine there is enough of it to take care of a crowd. And then with their culinary reputation, bad wine can’t be far behind. So it is somewhat possible. But I say the Brit Olympic story is the phony.


  6. C sounds fakest to me


  7. Oh, you wanted the one false answer, huh? That’s not how they play it on “Wait Wait.” I’m guessing B is the fake story.


  8. Has to be A. Not in China.


  9. Let’s see, I know D is true because I just read the story. A sounds crazy so it must be true. B is plausible, but the English love their beer way too much so C is NOT true. :)


  10. C


  11. Hey all –

    Thanks for playing along. I’ll reveal the winning answer tomorrow–de dum! The suspense…

    Ron – Yes, there were three crazy/silly wine stories that I saw in the wine news so I decided to switch it from the show and do only one fictional story. Still, you get to separate fact from fiction!


  12. well, i read the first two online recently – although that doesn’t make them true. i’m gonna guess (D) – there isn’t any legal framework for how to arrange a wine shop that i know of. besides, alice ferring would be all over that story if it had happened.


  13. This blog is great! I like this blog..
    Let’s see, I know D is true because I just read the story. A sounds crazy so it must be true. B is plausible, but the English love their beer way too much so C is NOT true.


  14. [...] Bluff the reader wine challenge! [...]


  15. I would never disbelieve a story about China’s antics, so probably C-London – there’s nothing low-priced there.


  16. Hi all –

    Thanks for playing–hope you enjoyed it.

    The fake story (thus, the correct answer) is C. Too bad, though since wouldn’t that be fun at the Olympics!

    Here are links to the other stories:

    http://shandong.chinadaily.com.cn/e/2012-07/03/content_15544973.htm

    http://www.ledauphine.com/drome/2012/07/05/un-pylone-de-18-metres-de-haut-sur-l-hermitage

    http://dobianchi.com/2012/07/10/natural-wine-italian-government-crackdown/


  17. Pretty sure it’s C. Good job on the phony story, though.


winepoliticsamz

Wine Maps


Classes

My next NYU wine classes: NYU

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

See my op-eds in the NYT
"Drink Outside the Box"
"Red, White, and Green"

Highlights

Monthly Archives

Categories


Blog posts via email


@drvino








Wine industry jobs

quotes

One of the “fresh voices taking wine journalism in new and important directions.” -World of Fine Wine

“His reporting over the past six months has had seismic consequences, which is a hell of an accomplishment for a blog.” -Forbes.com

"News of such activities, reported last month on a wine blog called Dr. Vino, have captivated wine enthusiasts and triggered a fierce online debate…" The Wall Street Journal

"...well-written, well-researched, calm and, dare we use the word, sober." -Dorothy Gaiter & John Brecher, WSJ

jbf07James Beard Foundation awards

Saveur, best drinks blog, finalist 2012.

Winner, Best Wine Blog

One of the "seven best wine blogs." Food & Wine,

One of the three best wine blogs, Fast Company

See more media...

ayow150buy

Wine books on Amazon: