Moncuit, Roagna, Cascina della Rose, Arnot-Roberts – Polaner highlights

It’s the time of year when distributors and/or importers have annual (or semi-annual) portfolio tastings. These are opportunities for breadth, not depth, as hundreds of current release wines (and occasionally some older ones) are put out on tables, often with the winemaker pouring. Yesterday was the Polaner Selections tasting and I dropped by for a while in the second half. Below are a few impressions and photos.

moncuit champagne

Pierre Moncuit – Quite delicious champagnes, overall. Mostly the range consistes of blanc de blancs from Mesnil, but the rosé has 25% pinot noir from Ambonnay. The blanc de blancs grand cru [cuvée 2008] has depth and minerality, a stony core that pleasantly lingers. The Hugues de Coulmet has a creamier quality that is more easy going, while the vintage 2005 has a still-wine character that brings depth. The rosé has a lip-smacking acidity. All the wines have about 7-8g residual sugar.

roagna paje crichet
One of the most exciting tables in the large room had the Piedmontese wines of Roagna wines and Cascina delle Rose, new to me and new to Polaner. Luca Roagna makes an array of wines from a solid dolcetto all the way up to the impossible to find Crichet Paje. All the wines bear the signature of firm tannins that cry out for cellaring. The Crichet Paje on the table from 2002, a poor vintage but a great wine. Really, a WOW! kind of wine that has amazing complexity despite the relative youth.

cascina della rose barbaresco

The wines from Cascina delle Rose had more accessible tannins but that’s not to say they were soft; rather, the wines possess a gorgeous tannic intrigue of layered complexity. The dolcetto, which retails for about $20, is very pretty. The 2008 Barbarescos are delectable treats. It was a delight to discover the wines from this eight-acre estate and I will look out for them in the future.

wind gap pinot gris
Over in the domestic wine area, Pax Mahle of Wind Gap and Duncan and Erin Meyers of Arnot Roberts made for some good tasting. Of the Wind Gap wines, I found the 2010 Windsor Oaks Vineyard Pinot Gris, which sees about 100 days of skin contact and has a resulting orange-y hue, good acidity and a phenolic quality. Quite fun.

arnot roberts syrah
At Arnot-Roberts (pronounced “are-nit” since it’s Scottish, Duncan confirmed, not French), the luminescent 2011 rosé from Touriga nacional really has ebullient fruit, crackling acidity, and 12.4% alcohol. This whole cluster wine (not saigné) is a terrific vin de soif, if that still applies at $25 retail. The 2010 Clary Ranch Syrah had lots of similarities to a St. Joseph, including an alluring herbal quality, good weight and an elusive olive note.

There were lots of great wines in the room including Mascarello, Huet, and many more. (Sadly, Conterno was already gone by 2:30.) The apple and pear ciders from Eric Bordelet’s ancient trees were clean and enticing.

Were you there? What did you like?

Related Posts with Thumbnails

5 Responses to “Moncuit, Roagna, Cascina della Rose, Arnot-Roberts – Polaner highlights”

  1. For all the thirsty Chicagoans reading this and wondering “where is my Moncuit?” I’d like to assure that more is coming. Candid’s next batch of NV is being packed into a container this week…Of course we do have Vintage, Rose and half bottles in stock for now.

  2. Arnot Roberts Syrah north coast done with carbonic maceration as well as their Pinot Gris above were downright sadistically good.

  3. Where can a thirsty Chicagoan get a taste of the Arnot-Roberts Syrah? Missed it on my last trip to Sonoma.

  4. Damien – glad you are getting more for thirsty Chicagoans.

    Jeremy – Yes, that was another pinot gris unlike anybody’s grandmother’s pinot grigio.

    Greg – I checked for you and it appears no retailers stock Arnot-Roberts wine in Chicago. You might contact the winery to confirm; also, they could send the wine to you directly. Unfortunately, Illinois passed legislation a few years ago prohibiting out-of-state wine shops to send wine into Illinois, so you can’t order from a store in NY, for example.

  5. I tasted some old favorites :
    Bordelet, F. Chidaine, Huët, Trapet Père & fils, Agrapart, C. Bouchard, Moncuit, Moutard.

    And discovered some great wines:
    Classic Campania varietals by Ocone, Roagna’s La Pira and Chricet Pajé, Valle dell’Acate and their fruity, Sicilian Frappato, Lezcano-Lacalle’s Docetanidos rosé.

    Selosse was missed 🙁


Wine Maps

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

See my op-eds in the NYT
"Drink Outside the Box"
"Red, White, and Green"


Monthly Archives


Blog posts via email



Wine industry jobs


One of the “fresh voices taking wine journalism in new and important directions.” -World of Fine Wine

“His reporting over the past six months has had seismic consequences, which is a hell of an accomplishment for a blog.”

"News of such activities, reported last month on a wine blog called Dr. Vino, have captivated wine enthusiasts and triggered a fierce online debate…" The Wall Street Journal

"...well-written, well-researched, calm and, dare we use the word, sober." -Dorothy Gaiter & John Brecher, WSJ

jbf07James Beard Foundation awards

Saveur, best drinks blog, finalist 2012.

Winner, Best Wine Blog

One of the "seven best wine blogs." Food & Wine,

One of the three best wine blogs, Fast Company

See more media...


Wine books on Amazon: