Enlarge your Pinot dollar – Pinot under $20 – new world or old world?

bottleneck The whole concept of Pinot under $20 is enough to make some Burghounds shudder. But it is a topic of recurring interest to everyone at the Dr. Vino World Headquarters with its high concentration of frugal pinotphiles.

I recently had the $19 Nicolas Potel 2006 Bourgogne rouge and found it a great value, lean, old world pinot. In previous vintages, I’ve enjoyed value Pinots from Austria (e.g. Stadlmann) and Italy’s alto Alto Adige region (e.g. Hofstatter) as well. And I’ve had some good new world Pinot under $20, such as the “H” Pinot Noir from Hamacher in Oregon. (search for these wines)

What about you? Have your say in our latest poll!

Does better pinot noir under $20 come from the old world or the new world?

View Results

loading  Loading ...
pixel

20 Responses to “Enlarge your Pinot dollar – Pinot under $20 – new world or old world?”


  1. That is pretty tough. All-in-all, as a big Pinot fan (and big Burg fan) I tend to lean old-world, but it is pretty rare that I find good Pinot under 20 bucks, but sometimes I do, and then it tends to be pretty evenly divided. As we speak I am drinking an ’06 Ponzi Tavola Pinot Noir from the Willamette, picked up for the very reasonable price of 14.99. It is pretty good, with characteristics similar to an entry level bourgogne from a good house, though with a bit more new world styled sweetness. Very nice for the price, and moreover just plain nice.
    The one caveat for me is that the less expensive Pinot needs to be chilled a bit more than more expensive expressions of the grape. I think cellar temp is good, but I slight chill from the fridge works good for me too.


  2. That’s tough has there is a bit more good Pinot under 20 from old world, but a huge abundance of insipid bad old world as well.

    However, the best (my favorite) $20 Pinot comes from Cali. Calera Central Coast at $19.99. I can drink and buy this by the boatload.


  3. Try the 2007 Stephen Ross Central Coast Pinot Noir for right around $20 depending on where you live in the country! Performs above it’s price point and made by a small family owned 500 case winery.


  4. Classy headline Doc!

    I have to vote for both. I’ve found moderately priced pinot’s I enjoy from France by searching between the cracks and following recommendations (Clos du Tue-Boeuf Cheverny and Domaine Billard Bourgogne are both excellent values), Cali (Wyatt and Byron have been consistently good) and even So. America (Jelu from Argentina). They’re all different styles, but all enjoayable and under $20.


  5. …Voted “tough call” as, with all respect to the Old World, the value line from Cono Sur (Chile) is hard to beat…Grown sustainably (an Organic model is available) on their estates & drinks superbly.


  6. I haven’t had very much domestic Pinot under $20 that was great. I’ve had quite a few from Germany, Alsace, weird parts of France, and basic Burgundy that was good.

    I also had quite a bit of great stuff at a good price in the Okanagan in Canada.


  7. I’ve recently tried Pali which now has a few choices under $20. Alphabets and Huntington are out favorites. For the money its a no brainer. Their more expensive selection are even better but for the $ you will be hard pressed to find a better pinot.


  8. I’ve had a ton of great pinots from Burgundy for under $20


  9. My husband and I are big fans of Pinot but have found it difficult to find anything worth repeating under $20 until we started trying PALI too. They have 2 or 3 Pinot priced right at $20. I recommend trying Huntington


  10. Sounds like a Pali love-in. When I tasted the new Pali Pinots, the Huntington was still priced at $40, and it showed perfectly well. I was surprised when the winery sent out a press release advising that the price had dropped to $19. At that price, it is a bargain.

    Other wines that showed up as bargains in my tastings were:
    –Kenwood 2007 Russian River Valley, an amazing wine that tastes like Russian River Pinot. At $18, it outpoints its many of its AVA peers at twice the price. OK, its not Kosta Browne or Williams Selyem.

    Carmel Road Monterey bottling at $17 is another wine with lots of quality for the money.

    And if you are not familiar with the $12 Pinots of Castle Rock, and you are looking for priceworthy versions of the grape, try either the 2007 Sonoma County or the 2007 Mendocino County.


  11. I love Pinot, I prefer Burg, but there are some very good cali PN. Check out Tolosa PN San Louis Obisbo. Beautiful fruit forward Cali style. On of the better sub $20 PN I have tried recently.


  12. I think the problem with New World Pinot Noir (especially from Oz) is that the top half dozen under $20 are not exported.


  13. Why would anyone vote that Pinot under $20 has as much appeal as the dump bucket (19.0%, 39 Votes)? It seems to me people like to be ripped off. Name one other product where people would scoff at getting a deal. And if anyone out there thinks that decent Pinot Noir cannot be made for $20 they know nothing about winemaking and are willing to eat into marketing B.S.


  14. This cost me $10. 2007 Antugnac Pinot Noir. Not a Burgundy but produced by a Burgundian producer in southern France. Better than many CA pinots costing 3+ times that.
    The notion that it can’t be done or done consistently is not truthful.
    It’s marketing propaganda.


  15. I third/fourth the Pali wines and am the biggest fan of the Bluffs.


  16. Does anyone know where I can get some Pinot’s online and inexpensive wine for that matter?
    Thanks,
    Norm


  17. Check out http://www.finewinediscounters.com. I’ve purchased a lot of wine from them and they provide excellent server!
    -Frank


  18. Fleur Central Coast PN and Rock Point Oregon PN are both very tasty new world style and can be found around $15-17.


  19. Looks like the issue here is availability.

    If you all or yawl (depending on where yawl from) could get access to Oregon the way Virginia does then this discussion would most definitely be about which $40 Willamette Valley Pinot made you “poop your pants” or whose $90 Willamette Valley Pinot is worthy of a future orgy. Its almost as if the less you’ve heard about an Oregon Winery then the better they taste…Why…because “IF” they taste “THAT” “GOOD” “THEN” “WHY” “WOULD” “THEY” “TELL” “YOU”!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  20. Frank,
    Thanks for the referral of Fine Wine Discounters. Great selection of wine at very reasonable prices!!!
    Jack


winepoliticsamz

Wine Maps


Classes

My next NYU wine classes: NYU

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

See my op-eds in the NYT
"Drink Outside the Box"
"Red, White, and Green"

Highlights

Monthly Archives

Categories


Blog posts via email


@drvino








Wine industry jobs

quotes

One of the “fresh voices taking wine journalism in new and important directions.” -World of Fine Wine

“His reporting over the past six months has had seismic consequences, which is a hell of an accomplishment for a blog.” -Forbes.com

"News of such activities, reported last month on a wine blog called Dr. Vino, have captivated wine enthusiasts and triggered a fierce online debate…" The Wall Street Journal

"...well-written, well-researched, calm and, dare we use the word, sober." -Dorothy Gaiter & John Brecher, WSJ

jbf07James Beard Foundation awards

Saveur, best drinks blog, finalist 2012.

Winner, Best Wine Blog

One of the "seven best wine blogs." Food & Wine,

One of the three best wine blogs, Fast Company

See more media...

ayow150buy

Wine books on Amazon: