Watermelon: an impossible food wine pairing?

watermelon
What fruit encapsulates summer better than a watermelon? OK, I hear you muttering about peaches, nectarines, berries and that forgotten fruit–the tomato. But today’s challenge is watermelon! Is it an impossible food-wine pairing?

Have your say in the comments! And do let us know if you’re pairing that $6,100 black watermelon just sold in Japan or a plain old regular one instead.

pixel

27 Responses to “Watermelon: an impossible food wine pairing?”


  1. Watermelon on its own? I’m not sure there’d be much point in pairing wine with something so juicy, fun and fleetingly consumed. Then again, a good, fruit forward rosé from Provence goes just about perfectly with the salad of watermelon, tomatoes, mint and feta I’ve been known to prepare. So it would probably work out just fine with a solo slice of melon.


  2. The comment about the impossibly expensive watermelon in Japan got me to thinking… I would actually pair watermelon with an unfiltered Sake, not exactly wine but it’s got similar flavor characteristics.


  3. i have never paried watermelon with wine and probably never will. but my first thought was something like a Vinho Verde – more specifically a Rosé Vinho Verde if you can find it.

    watermelon and wine is a risky proposition, so what better than to take a risky guess.


  4. I like to put a little salt on my watermelon. So a wine w/ a bit of salinity would be my choice. Maybe a Muscadet, but even better would Txacoli. Rose Txacoli often has hints of watermelon, but alas I tend to like the white versions better.


  5. Rose? torrontes? malvasia bianca? gewurztraminer, sweeter rieslings and rose cava, rose champagne (cremant).


  6. Rose? its the same colour at least hah


  7. Stacy, I actually really like the idea of sake!

    David, maybe watermelon sorbet then?

    How about a moscato d’asti?


  8. If I had to pair watermelon with a wine I would look for a light pink sparkling wine. I think the bubbles would be just the thing with the texture of the melon.


  9. When it comes to watermelon I would suggest wines from Domaine Zind-Humbrecht from Alsace, France. Which one exactly is hard to say. They have a range from super-dry to super-honey-sweet so the best thing would be: 6 – 10 poeple, enough watermelon and half-a-dozend diffent Zind-Humbrecht wines from dry to sweet. An’ let’s find out which one suits best!

    But I must say, Moscato d’Asti is also a good idea.


  10. What, doesn’t anyone like to cut a hole in the melon and fill the sucker with vodka anymore? Just askin’…


  11. I could imagine a mosel riesling with maybe 7.5 or 8% alcohol…


  12. I’m not sure I would attempt the pairing either. But Innocent Bystander out of Australia has a sparkling pink moscato that I’m sure would do the trick.

    But since you mentioned watermelon, I always think of Petey Greene, How to Eat a Watermelon. I’m not sure he would recommend the pairing.


  13. Tish- my college roommates and I still enjoy watermelon and vodka on a hot summer day- so don’t worry, you’re not alone.

    However, I made them try this and it is exceptional: Small cube of watermelon with a scoop out of the middle, topped with a slice of Parmesan Reggiano and drizzled in delicious balsamic vinegar. Perfect combination of sweet, salty an savory. We enjoyed it a pinot noir – very good. Fresh summer appetizer.


  14. Watermelon?

    Odd that someone would want to drink wine with it, but I think a demi-sec champagne or a Kabinett Riesling would match up nicely. If you have the prerequsite fried yard bird as an accompaniment, then I would go for a brut rose Champagne.

    The Count has spoken!


  15. I agree, a nice 2007 Mosel-Saar-Ruwer Kabinett (St. Urbans-Hof, J.J. Prum, yadda yadda) or some beautiful BUGEY CERDON! The Bubbly of Kings!


  16. Bwerts, I agree the watermelon vodka trick is good. I’ll definitely have to try that version you mentioned with the Balsamic though!

    I work over at Tin Cross Vineyards where we have some great apricots growing on the land. I have done a sort of breakfast for dinner before: I was doing a reduction with the apricots, sugar, butter and a Sauvignon Blanc, and then added that as fruit filling to crepes. The rest of the wine was used for drinking along side the dish. Great stuff.

    I wonder about raw watermelon though, I’ll give test it out since I just bought a big, ripe one. But, it’s hard to say what wine would work well, perhaps a Riesling?


  17. I’d make watermelon ice cubes and put them in some sparkling wine (cava or champagne would work too). See here for the recipe: http://www.gastronomersguide.com/2008/08/watermelon-and-mint-ice-cubes.html


  18. Since watermelons have been found to have viagra like qualities without the side effect and red wines have resveratrol, I’ll go with that


  19. I paired watermelon and tomato salad (as described above) with Adelsheim Rose of Pinot Noir. Outstanding!


  20. Even though I am a wino at heart … LOL … watermelon and vodka are like peanut butter and jelly!

    I surprised my guests the other night with watermelon/vodka sorbet … of course it didn’t freeze all the way, but it was mighty tasty on a hot summer night!

    Denise
    http://WineFoodPairing.blogspot.com


  21. Perfect match:

    Vodka/watermelon and getting smashed with Tish!


  22. since martini stole my bugey cerdon idea, i’d have to say prosecco


  23. I’ve found a sweet dessert wine does quite nicely. A personal favorite is from the Cowichan Valley in British Columbia Canada: Venturi-Shulze’s Brandenburg Number Three.


  24. I, now, live in Brazil and that means paring fruit with wine is a quite usual..
    Brazilian sparking wines (Miolo Milesime, Salton Sedução)_ as good as Cava _ is a refresh summer drink when mixed together.. and if you want to make it sexy, try put a little bit of ginger in the mix.. and don’t forget my royalties creditis..


  25. [...] And people often want to experiment and pair wine with with non-traditional foods, such as watermelon soup, so he has to think creatively. He’ll give you a 10% discount for a case purchase and even [...]


  26. Amarone. Kidding. Clairette de Die. Sparkling moscato-freisa.


  27. I really don’t think any champagne will work at all. The sweetness of the watermelon will make any champagne tastes painfully acidic. One thinks that a Bugey may work, but I doubt it —
    I had a wine with some RS with just plain berries two weeks ago, and the off-dry Austria GruVe tastes like lemonade (it was the 05 Prager Stockkultur).

    An intriguing idea would be something actually tannic and bubbly (like the SYP Naked On Roller Skate sparkling shiraz) or something with salinity in it, like a particularly saline Asyrtiko from Santorini.


winepoliticsamz

Wine Maps


Classes

My next NYU wine classes: NYU

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

See my op-eds in the NYT
"Drink Outside the Box"
"Red, White, and Green"

Highlights

Monthly Archives

Categories


Blog posts via email


@drvino








Wine industry jobs

quotes

One of the “fresh voices taking wine journalism in new and important directions.” -World of Fine Wine

“His reporting over the past six months has had seismic consequences, which is a hell of an accomplishment for a blog.” -Forbes.com

"News of such activities, reported last month on a wine blog called Dr. Vino, have captivated wine enthusiasts and triggered a fierce online debate…" The Wall Street Journal

"...well-written, well-researched, calm and, dare we use the word, sober." -Dorothy Gaiter & John Brecher, WSJ

jbf07James Beard Foundation awards

Saveur, best drinks blog, finalist 2012.

Winner, Best Wine Blog

One of the "seven best wine blogs." Food & Wine,

One of the three best wine blogs, Fast Company

See more media...

ayow150buy

Wine books on Amazon: