Sherry-Lehmann: the best new wine store that you don’t need to visit


The venerable wine retailer Sherry-Lehmann moved and I couldn’t wait to check out the new digs. After all, with so much innovation in New York City wine shops, I was eager to see how the management of this patrician shop capitalized on the opportunity to do something different with their new space at Park Avenue at 59th Street.

They didn’t. It’s lighter, with windows on two sides now. But it’s still compact, now with less friendly displays.

On my visit, two things caught my eye as I browsed. First, all the bottles are locked down. And I’m not talking just the Petrus–even the $9.99 pinot grigio is clamped to the shelf. Wow, shades of Paris, not BottleRocket! I guess you can’t be too careful at 59th and Park.

Second, there are no shelf talkers. You know, those little flaps of paper that usually bark out a score. I use this as a cursory indicator of whether a wine shop “feels the love,” with staff-written flaps being the most loving and distributor print-outs being the least. What to do in the absence of a flap?

Ask someone. Eegad–human interaction! In a couple of paces I was at the counter where many tie-wearing men were keeping themselves busy. One broke away and asked if I needed help. Feeling summery, I said that I was looking for a Soave since I have previously bought the excellent Pieropan there for $17 (find this wine). We walked over to a computer terminal in the aisle and the sales rep tapped and clicked. Apparently I could have done this computer inquiry myself (a nod to the new wave of wine shops? Or a page out of Border’s book?).

The search generated four Soaves, one of which was out of stock and the other two were just in the warehouse, for next day delivery. The fourth the sales rep was not familiar with so I didn’t leap at that. On to the next thing: cru Beaujolais?

Indeed they had a small shelf dedicated to cru Beaujolais, dominated by several DuBoeuf offerings. I spotted a bottle of 04 Chateau des Jacques, which I had just enjoyed in a recent Bojo tasting, and for $15/bottle, I snapped it up (find this wine). Well, I didn’t actually take the bottle from the shelf since it was locked down. But I told my affable sales rep that I would like it, he tapped into his handheld device, which sent my request to the basement storage room where my order was printed out. We stepped to the register and he rang me up and the bottle appeared slightly afterwards.

What’s striking in the New Sherry-Lehmann is that it is so similar to the Old Sherry-Lehmann. With newcomers such as Moore Brothers offering the entire store chilled to 60 degree store and a kids play area, BottleRocket offering enticing displays of food and wine pairings, Crush with breathtaking design, Astor’s quirky shelf-talkers, the New Sherry-Lehmann remains stuck in a bygone era of wine shop design. Not that it is necessarily bad. Just striking.

If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it must be the prevailing logic. The storefront actually seems somewhat superfluous since belies a massive back-end operation with a 65,000 square foot, climate-controlled facility in Brooklyn (now THAT I would like to see!).

Sherry-Lehmann has come through for me on a number of occasions in the past year and it remains without a doubt one of the top wine shops in the city. I find their selection to be quite good, the staff on the phone to be friendly and knowledgeable, and their next-day delivery to be excellent. But won’t be rushing back to the small showroom itself. Why go to the store, after all, when with a quick phone call, they’ll bring it to you?
505 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10022, (212) 838-7500.
See it on the map of NYC wine shops

Related Posts with Thumbnails

9 Responses to “Sherry-Lehmann: the best new wine store that you don’t need to visit”

  1. What do you do if you want to see the back of the bottle?

  2. What bothers me about that whole interaction is that the salesman had to go to a computer terminal to find out what was available/where it was – as far as I’m concerned, he should have been able to walk you right over to the section and point to the Soaves that were on offer (I understand needing to check for how many bottles are in stock) – and if he’s “on the floor” it’s inexcusable that he doesn’t know the wines. That’s what he’s being paid for, right? Maybe he needs to spend less time chatting with coworkers at the register and more learning his job.

  3. Wow, I’ve always wanted to go to SL having visited their website so many times, and having ordered from them. Now, I know I don’t need to. They’re basically an e-commerce site or direct mail catalog with a small facade of a storefront…

  4. I went there on a trip to NY and I found the salesperson condescending. I don’t need that. If you have to use them, it seems the web site is the friendly way. I liked the staff at Burgundy Wine Co. and even Crush better, but SL has the selection…

  5. Joe, I’ve been to SL four times over the last year. They love me. I thought they were the pinnacle of customer service.

    Have to check out the new store…

  6. I haven’t been to the new store but placed a phone order one day, for wines that had to be delivered in Manahattan that afternoon. I was shocked at how many things I asked for were “not in the store. they’re in the warehouse and we can have them here tomorrow.” That’s not making me jump to stop in…

  7. What about Discovery Wines? It is the best, most interesting wine store in the city!

  8. I’m from California and was looking forward to visiting their new store next time im in NY…until now… lol. I’ll still go of course but thanks for the info so I won’t get my hopes up.
    That’s sad… the store is gorgeous from the outside but seems rather cold on the inside. Putting all wines behind bars… doesn’t seem right.
    They do have the best website I’ve ever encountered when it comes to ordering wine online. Used S-L to order our company Christmas gifts to multiple destinations, and it was super-easy to do. (Just wanted to end it on a positve note). 🙂

  9. SL is one of my favorite stores anywhere. They have great selection, knowledgeable, helpful staff, good prices, and, at their former location, a handsome facility. I very much look forward to visiting their new digs next week.


Wine Maps

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

See my op-eds in the NYT
"Drink Outside the Box"
"Red, White, and Green"


Monthly Archives


Blog posts via email



Wine industry jobs


One of the “fresh voices taking wine journalism in new and important directions.” -World of Fine Wine

“His reporting over the past six months has had seismic consequences, which is a hell of an accomplishment for a blog.”

"News of such activities, reported last month on a wine blog called Dr. Vino, have captivated wine enthusiasts and triggered a fierce online debate…" The Wall Street Journal

"...well-written, well-researched, calm and, dare we use the word, sober." -Dorothy Gaiter & John Brecher, WSJ

jbf07James Beard Foundation awards

Saveur, best drinks blog, finalist 2012.

Winner, Best Wine Blog

One of the "seven best wine blogs." Food & Wine,

One of the three best wine blogs, Fast Company

See more media...


Wine books on Amazon: